Denève: Prokofiev's Violin
Program Notes
From an early age, Sergei Prokofiev grew accustomed to having things go his way. His father was a Moscow-educated agricultural scientist who managed a vast estate in the fertile plains of Ukraine’s Donetsk region, representing the interests of its noble owner who had been a classmate in school. Prokofiev’s mother, born a serf (the Russian Empire’s form of quasi-slavery that bound peasants to the noblemen who owned the land they worked), embraced the freedom and access to culture that came with her new social status, especially the delight of playing piano. The couples’ first two children died young, and so Prokofiev was doted upon as an only child with two highly engaged parents and a whole team around them. His father supervised his general education; his mother taught him piano and other arts; various governesses taught him French and German; an older cousin got him hooked on chess. His playmates were the children of the estate’s laborers, who addressed him formally and treated him with the deference befitting their class divide.
Prokofiev began inventing his own little pieces as soon as his mother started giving him piano lessons at age four, and by 10 he was already working on his second opera. The family consulted with a professor at the Moscow Conservatory and arranged for a recent graduate, Reinhold Gliere, to come spend the summer as a live-in composition teacher. Under his supervision, the 11-year-old Prokofiev drafted his earliest attempt at a symphony. After two summers of working with Gliere and some additional tutoring to prep him for the entrance exam, the 13-year-old Prokofiev was admitted to the Saint Petersburg Conservatory, where he breezed through the composition curriculum and continued on to study piano and conducting. When he graduated with the highest honors in 1914, he was already a published composer and a star pianist who was making waves performing the two concertos he wrote for himself.
All the while, the solid ground beneath Prokofiev’s feet was shifting, musically and politically. In music, everyone was buzzing about the Ballets Russes and the sensational dance scores being written for them by the previously unknown Igor Stravinsky. Prokofiev’s graduation present in 1914 was a trip to London that coincided with a Ballet Russes residency there, and he heard Stravinsky’s radical trifecta of folk-influenced ballets: The Firebird, Petrouchka and The Rite of Spring. He also got to meet and play for the troupe’s impresario, Serge Diaghilev, who was impressed enough to commission a ballet from him. Prokofiev went home and made his best effort at a ritualistic dance score in the mold of Stravinsky’s Rite, but Diaghilev didn’t care for it and canceled the project.
The tension between Prokofiev’s natural proclivity to write elegant, impeccable music and the currents of the day that favored wild experimentation would become a lifelong source of conflict for the composer. In the aftermath of the failed ballet that he recycled into the gargantuan Scythian Suite, he tacked the opposite way and challenged himself to write a symphony that would live up to the standards of clarity, balance and wit established by the father of that quintessential Classicalera genre, Joseph Haydn. Supplanting the juvenile efforts he had abandoned, this became his true Symphony No. 1 in D major, known quite rightly as the “Classical” Symphony. By embracing those Classical paradigms (along with rhythms and stylistic conventions from the earlier Baroque era), Prokofiev invented his own “neoclassical” sound a few years before Stravinsky and his many imitators made that a cornerstone of 20th-century style.
A leading orchestra in Haydn’s day operated out of the royal court in Mannheim, Germany, and one of their signature moves was the rising “Mannheim Rocket,” which Prokofiev mimicked with the explosive arpeggio that launches the “Classical” Symphony. The first movement’s other main theme, played by the violins as they navigate absurdly wide leaps, shows how effectively Prokofiev used parody and exaggeration to simultaneously celebrate and skewer his source material.
The Larghetto second movement centers on a singing theme that enters in the clear treble of the violins. A contrasting middle section introduces a steady trickle of 16th-notes, and then the closing passage interweaves both sounds. Instead of a Haydn-style minuet or Beethoven-style scherzo, the Symphony turns next to a Gavotte, a staple of French dance suites from the Baroque era. The finale races to the finish on a stream of whirlwind eighth-notes, with interlocking rhythmic patterns and seamless handoffs between sections that make for the musical equivalent of a relay race.
The political earthquakes that shattered Prokofiev’s life in Russia were the Revolutions of 1917. After years of fierce fighting in World War I that killed millions of young Russian men and pushed the entire empire to the brink of starvation and economic collapse, workers initiated a massive strike in February of 1917, which escalated into a riot that only relented when Tsar Nicholas II abdicated. Various factions jockeyed for power over the next eight months, until Vladimir Lenin returned from years of exile to lead his far-left Bolshevik party and its surging army of workers in a rapid takeover of the government in Saint Petersburg. Civil War broke out and Lenin’s forces prevailed, establishing him as the first leader of a new Soviet republic.
Prokofiev responded to these events by retreating with his mother to the Caucasus, a thousand miles from the centers of conflict. His nine months there were some of the most productive of his life; besides finishing the “Classical” Symphony, he adapted old sketches into his Third and Fourth Piano Sonatas, and he built on earlier ideas to draft his Violin Concerto No. 1 in D major.
Without being quite as explicit about borrowing historical mannerisms, the First Violin Concerto shares the “Classical” Symphony’s tendencies toward clarity and tunefulness, starting with a quiet and disarmingly vulnerable melody from the violin. The gentle sway of the triple meter gives way to square, pulsing beat and a contrasting theme from the violin that Prokofiev marked narrante, meaning that it should be delivered as if telling a story. The central Scherzo introduces a scurrying melodies over a churning accompaniment, and the finale also establishes a precise, clock-like foundation for a free-floating theme. These kinds of textures, featuring exploratory melodies set over propulsive patterns and cycling ostinatos, became a lifelong sonic signature for Prokofiev.
Prokofiev left his hideaway in 1918 and returned to Saint Petersburg (by then renamed Petrograd) for just long enough to secure a visa to travel abroad. With World War I still raging to the west, he took a train to Siberia, crossed to Japan and then sailed eastward from Tokyo through Honolulu and on to San Francisco, where he was suspected of being a Bolshevik spy and briefly detained. He was all but broke as he continued by train to New York, and his efforts to book piano recitals were complicated by the Spanish flu that was ravaging the country. For the first time in his life, Prokofiev found himself backed into a corner with no easy options. It turned out to be a predicament he would have to learn to endure.
As Prokofiev tried to break into the U.S. recital circuit, he realized quite quickly that American audiences already swooning over another Russian expatriate, Sergei Rachmaninoff; in comparison, Prokofiev’s more austere style of playing and thornier original repertoire landed with a thud. He began spending parts of each year in Europe, and after four years of mounting frustration, he moved to Germany in 1922. Encouraged by a series of well-received performances in Paris, he relocated there the next year with his new bride, a Spanish singer.
There in the epicenter of the avant-garde, where Stravinsky held court as the king of a cutting-edge neoclassical style, and the young French mavericks known as Les six were making waves with their own sassy extensions of that trend, Prokofiev tried for a time to stake his claim as a cutting-edge modernist, with varying levels of success. After a few years in that mode that still yielded scant career progress, Prokofiev found himself drawn back toward his “Classical” proclivities and a style he called “new simplicity,” which was increasingly out of step with the prevailing tastes in Europe. But it turned out there was an audience receptive to his sound—back in his homeland.
After nearly a decade away, Prokofiev returned to the Soviet Union in 1927 for a concert tour and was greeted as a hero. Several more visits followed, along with high-profile commissions that offered an enticing vision of the opportunities awaiting him under the patronage of an all-powerful party apparatus.
It was against that backdrop that Prokofiev accepted a commission to compose the Violin Concerto No. 2 in G minor for the French violinist Robert Soetans in 1935. Prokofiev worked on it in Paris and during another concert tour of the Soviet Union, completing it in time for the scheduled debut that December in Madrid, where the local audience surely appreciated Prokofiev’s inclusion of castanets in the orchestration.
The Second Violin Concerto fulfills the promise of a “new simplicity” from its opening measures, entrusting an unadorned theme to the solo violin. That melody haunts the first movement, ultimately silencing a contrasting lyrical strain and returning for a charged final statement with bellicose plucks. The slow movement takes up the same ascending triad pattern that began the first movement, transporting it to a peaceful accompanying texture for clarinets and pizzicato strings. The solo violin floats above with a melody of timeless beauty and grace, soaring into the instrument’s highest range as the theme passes to the orchestra. In the finale, the lumbering main theme and burly accompaniment patterns bastardize a simple dance rhythm, affirming Prokofiev’s lifelong knack for good-natured parody. The music builds to a propulsive coda, the violin’s perpetual motion figures urged forward by a thudding bass drum and throbbing accompaniment.
The Second Violin Concerto turned out to be Prokofiev’s very last commission outside of the Soviet Union. He moved with his wife and two sons to Moscow in 1936 with the expectation that he would still be able to travel for engagements in the West, but then in 1938 he was asked to turn in his passport, and he was never able to leave the country again. At least, for a time, Prokofiev was able to pour his creative efforts into the sorts of large theatrical projects that had so often fizzled in the U.S. and Europe, including the ballets Romeo and Juliet (1938) and Cinderella (1944), the opera War and Peace (1942), and film scores for Sergei Eisenstein’s Alexander Nevsky (1938) and Ivan the Terrible (1944). In an eerie echo of his earlier life, he evaded the havoc of World War II by spending part of 1944 at a rural retreat, where he completed three stunning piano sonatas from earlier sketches and the Fifth Symphony that made him a wartime hero.
The premiere of the ballet Cinderella in 1945 marked a high point in Prokofiev’s long journey around the globe and back to a place of honor in his native culture. It was also a stylistic homecoming of sorts, as he returned to the “Classical” conventions of his First Symphony to match the scenario’s 18th-century setting. The cheekiest moment of the Ballet was probably the scene where he quoted one of his own earlier works, rolling out the memorable March from his 1919 opera, The Love for Three Oranges. This was a work he had conceived in those feverish final months in Russia, and he worked on the libretto during that long voyage to New York, adapting an 18th-century Italian play from the whimsical Commedia dell’arte tradition. He secured a commission for it from an opera company in Chicago, and during the two-year delay in getting it staged, he also extracted a Suite from The Love for Three Oranges for concert performances. The opera never caught on in the West, but it became a repertoire staple in the Soviet Union after first appearing in Moscow in 1926, helping to pave the way for Prokofiev’s eventual homecoming.
When Prokofiev composed The Love for Three Oranges for an American audience, he challenged himself to use the most straightforward, direct style possible, building on his recent developments in the “Classical” Symphony and related pieces. The opera begins with a frame story that introduces opposing camps—Comedians, Tragedians, Lyricists and Empty Heads—who argue about the virtues of their preferred theatrical forms, a debate rendered in the suite’s opening number, The Clowns. Then the bulk of the opera unfolds as a theatrical performance set in an imaginary kingdom, where a prince, sick from consuming too much tragedy, can only be cured by laughter. When he chuckles at the expense of a witch, she curses him with a “love for three oranges.”
In the opera’s second act, that playful March introduces the outdoor entertainment staged to try to make the prince laugh. The Scherzo, from the third act, closes the scene in which the prince treks through the desert, cloaked by a storm, on his way to find the oranges. The three oranges turn out to conceal three fairy princesses; two die, but the prince saves the third and falls in love with her, as heard in the romantic strains of The Prince and Princess. The thrilling perpetual motion themes of The Flight represent the escape of the witch and her evil conspirators, leaving the prince and princess free to enjoy their own happily ever after.
Whatever creative freedom Prokofiev enjoyed following his repatriation vanished after World War II, when the Communist party exerted renewed control over every aspect of Soviet life. Prokofiev was among the elite composers condemned by name in a notorious decree from 1948, and he never came out from under that cloud. He lived five more years, his health failing and his spirit broken, until he died on the very same day as his tormenter, Joseph Stalin.
Life did not go the way that Prokofiev must have imagined it would when he was a precocious boy delighting in the small, idyllic world around him. And yet through all of his trials, that sense of delight never faded in his music. In the fullness of time he is finally appreciated as the kindly, clever genius he always was, with an unmistakable voice that transcends eras and borderlines.
– © 2026 Aaron Grad
Aaron Grad is a composer and writer based in Seattle. In addition to providing program notes for the New World Symphony, Orpheus Chamber Orchestra, Baltimore Symphony Orchestra and others, he is also the artistic director of Many Messiahs, a project that reframes George Frideric Handel’s masterpiece as a collective call for justice.